Monday, 17 December 2012

Reading Group Report: Edward Lloyd's 'The Christmas Log' and Victorian Christmas Stories


Led by Sarah Lill (Northumbria)


Northumbria University, 10 December 2012.



Our December reading group focused upon a short story by Edward Lloyd, whose festive title, ‘The Christmas Log’ soon proved to be deceptive in both tone and intent.  In contrast to the Dickensian Christmas story involving goodwill to all men, members found themselves reading an altogether different tale centred upon inheritance, illegitimacy and a desire to gain wealth.  The story concerns the efforts of a rich elderly gentleman to judge whether the beneficiaries of his will are worthy of their inheritance, a test which they fail miserably.  In contrast to Dickens’ emphasis upon Christmas as bringing out kindness and morality amongst all social classes, we thus considered why it was that Lloyd focuses instead upon their immorality, greed and selfishness.

An early observation was that there is little evidence that this is a Christmas story at all, with the title seeming anomalous to the plot.  Sarah was able to shed light on this by commenting that Lloyd often recycled successful stories that earned him profits, and that unlike Dickens, he wrote primarily from a pecuniary, rather than moral perspective.  Furthermore, it was suggested that Lloyd was more journalistic in intent, as opposed to Dickens’ preoccupation with being a great writer of novels.  However, despite the differences we observed between Lloyd’s and Dickens’ agendas, we could not help but wonder whether Lloyd’s attempt at a Christmas story was a deliberate marketing ploy to compete with the well-established Dickensian yuletide tale.

We found it interesting that Lloyd had a longstanding feud with Dickens, after plagiarising many of the latter’s works, and even managed to win a legal battle on the grounds that only ‘the stupidest of people’ could confuse the two writers.  By the late 1840s Lloyd’s interest in producing fiction was secondary to his attempts to establish a newspaper for the working classes.  Nevertheless, we discussed the ways in which he forged an identity as a writer, and to what extent his techniques were meant to subvert the wholesomeness of Dickensian Christmas stories.  It is perhaps no coincidence that it was during the 1840s that contemporary concepts of Christmas were born, such as the practice of giving gifts, Christmas trees and Christmas entertainment.  We considered whether Lloyd could be seen to capitalise upon these developing traditions, as ‘The Christmas Log’ seems to belong in music hall culture, and the rising phenomenon of the Christmas show.

In addition to discussing the way that Lloyd’s story fits into changing notions of Christmas, we also considered the extent to which the narrative, with its caricatures of unpleasant protagonists, outcast orphans and lone moral voice, belongs to an older Christmas tradition.  In particular, we related the plot to the telling of Christmas ghost stories, and considered whether in this context, the story is as alien to Lloyd’s usual tales of horror and criminality as it initially appears. We also wondered whether stories like it were intended to appeal to a wider social readership than Dickens’ writing, especially in terms of the way that a working class reader could enjoy the downfall of the social-climbing Jarvises, and the triumph of the orphan Marianne.  In this respect, we considered whether Lloyd’s work could be read as containing a moral message, and whether the theme of good punishing evil at Christmas time simply worked in a different way in his writing.

We found it significant that this is Lloyd’s only known Christmas story, a fact explained by his financial ambitions, and that his publications were steered by their ability to make a profit.  Nevertheless, we identified Lloyd’s commitment to developing an unusual literary style, which cannot solely be attributed to these monetary motivations.  In particular, there seems to be a distinctive journalistic tone to his published works that recalls his efforts to reach a working class readership.  We were interested by the fact that Lloyd hired others to write for him, yet at the same time, seemed to exercise an extensive creative influence over the works he published.  Certainly, his founding of mock newspapers with thinly-disguised attempts at delivering genuine news, implies that he was concerned not only with the medium in which he published, but also the content and form that his writing took.

Overall, members enjoyed reading an unconventional Christmas text, and discussing the wider issues it raised in relation to Victorian readership, society and print culture.  Although Lloyd would later distance himself from his early identity as a writer of fiction, we found this tension between his stories and his journalistic ambitions to be a rich and rewarding discussion point. 


Leanne Stokoe, Newcastle University.      

19 comments:

  1. You need to use dim eyeliner towards the top and also replica chanel truck tops leaving behind the most notable somewhat smudged. African american or perhaps greyish vision shadow needs to be utilized cautiously and also consistently. You can even atart exercising . mascara with it. It is possible to use white lipstick for the transformation you are carrying out and also help make brain switch. Head out right now there and also replica hublot watches the entire world. To get the particular styles up to date, a single must contain the cotton bags and also high end cheap rolex replica regarding diverse shades, designs, end, and so forth. Each trend lover could have a number of the low-cost buckskin fake hublot with their particular removal while they appreciate the will need of the low priced, large energy hand bags have become crucial, due to the fact a single can not foresee any time these kinds of may well can be found in helpful. Just like some other high end bags, they're furthermore regarding fantastic top quality, yet use a less expensive. On the internet web sites and lots of wholesalers, it is possible to have the replica rolex of most sorts with low-cost rates, which includes motivated many individuals to look or perhaps the particular less costly bags.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is exceptionally useful and great articles and I like this article. We can without much of a stretch comprehend this article in light of the fact that the writer did not utilize extreme and awful dialects and plainly indicates all the data about the topic.Some articles have not taking after the right composition arrange but rather here i got better approach for composing. I like the method for composing and the presenting.Keep sharing.I will share this article for my companions and partners.
    custom essay writing service

    ReplyDelete
  3. Delighted to be here,lot of interesting things i found here,thanks for sharing.
    bangalore escort

    ReplyDelete
  4. This 12th Man Banner for the Seattle Seahawks measures 28x40 inches and provides a 2 inch top sleeve for insertion of a flagpole or banner pole. Our 12th Man Banner for the Seattle Seahawks hangs vertically, is made of 100% thick polyester, features permanent Screen Printed Number 12 logos, and is Viewable and Readable Correctly on Both Sides.This house flag is Officially Licensed by the NFL and Seattle Seahawks and is a high quality item for hanging from your porch or as an interior wall banner.Hang your 12th Man Banner for the Seattle Seahawks with our banner pole or fly it with our 5' or 6' flagpoles and adjustable flag brackets.dallas cowboys american flag
    cowboys stars and stripes flagsNew England Patriots stars and stripes flags
    cheap New Orleans Saints american banners, House Divided Flags,Sports Flags 3x5, Sports flags and banners,nfl House Divided Flags

    ReplyDelete
  5. Il Pescara 2016-17 via kit è prevalentemente di colore giallo e dispone di una stampa grafica elaborata in blu e bianco sulla parte anteriore. Ulteriori finiture blu a forma di colletto e polsini completano la camicia via Pescara 16-17.
    Un altro disegno pulito, il terzo camicia Pescara 2016-2017 è di colore blu scuro con una striscia orizzontale bianca e blu sul davanti.maglie da calcio a poco prezzo,
    magliette da calcio poco prezzo, nuove Maglia Atletico Madrid prezzo
    Maglia Barcelona prezzo

    ReplyDelete
  6. I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read.
    Call Girls Service Dwarka

    ReplyDelete
  7. I read that Post and got it fine and enlightening. It is really helpful thanks for sharing with us.
    Call Girls South Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  8. Nice! thank you so much! Thank you for sharing. Your blog posts are more interesting and informative. I think there are many people like and visit it regularly, including me.
    http://www.delhigurgaon.in/
    Gurgaon Escorts Services

    ReplyDelete
  9. Here is good information for us thanks for sharing with us.
    Call Girls Service in Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  10. This is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks for sharing this great article! That is very interesting i love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this!

    Affordable Escorts Services in Gurgaon
    Affordable Female Escorts in Delhi
    Beautiful Russian Escorts in Gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  11. Don't you need to avail our happy hour offers with Indian call girls in Dubai?
    Indian Escort Dubai

    ReplyDelete
  12. I am very much pleased with the contents you have mentioned. I wanted to thank you for this great blog.
    Female Gurgaon Escort Services

    ReplyDelete
  13. Much required such a variety for an awesome publish. I'd like to know more about these points and trust that I can get more understanding into this topic.
    Gurgaon Escorts | Escorts in Gurgaon | Gurgaon Escorts | Independent Escorts in Gurgaon | Model Escorts in Gurgaon | Female Escorts in Gurgaon

    ReplyDelete