Thursday, 24 November 2011

Reading Group Report: Romantic Correspondences

Romantic Correspondences: Myth-Making and Breaking in the Brontë letters to the Lake Poets

Led by Harriet Briggs and Beatrice Turner (Newcastle University)

Thursday, 17 November 2011, Northumbria University

Texts Discussed:

Letter from Charlotte Brontë to Robert Southey (1837)
Letter from Robert Southey to Charlotte Brontë (1837)
Letter from Branwell Brontë to William Wordsworth (1837)
Letter from Branwell Brontë to Hartley Coleridge (1840)
Letter from Charlotte Brontë to Hartley Coleridge (1840)
Poem by Hartley Coleridge, ‘He liv’d amidst th’ untrodden ways’ (1827) –a pastiche of Wordsworth’s ‘She dwelt amongst th’ untrodden ways’ (1798-9)


For the first time, the reading group was held at Northumbria University, and we were delighted to welcome members from various degree programmes. We began the session by examining what was meant by ‘Romantic correspondences’. This involved thinking about critical perceptions of a divide between the Eighteenth Century and Romanticism on the one hand, and Romanticism and the Victorian period on the other. By examining correspondence between figures from ‘different’ literary periods, we considered the complexity of these chronological divisions.

Discussion was opened with an introduction to each writer, with a view to thinking about literary inheritance. We considered how Hartley Coleridge is regarded as the quintessential ‘Romantic child’, brought up in the Lake Poets’s coterie at Keswick, and featuring in several of his father’s poems. However, Hartley struggled to live within this shadow of greatness. Whilst Hartley grew up during the Romantic period, Charlotte and Branwell Brontë were introduced to Romantic values retrospectively. We considered how Branwell sought to remake Romanticism in the 1840s, rather than embrace the Victorian innovations that characterised the novels of Charlotte, Emily and Anne. Although we were amused by Branwell’s self-projection as a Byronic hero in his letter to Wordsworth, we also thought about what this said about how Romanticism was construed in the Victoria era. Branwell’s tone is less egotistical in his letter to Hartley, and we wondered if he had learned anything from Wordsworth’s silence about how the Romantic legacy related to a different social context. This led to thoughts about how the period between the death of Byron in 1824 and the passing of the Reform Act in 1832 is often considered a literary ‘no man’s land’.

Secondly, we examined Southey’s letter to Charlotte, with its statement that literature is ‘not a career for a woman’. Nevertheless, we agreed that this is sympathetic to Charlotte’s aspirations, with Southey referring to personal experience on the difficulties of being a writer, and his memories of a radical youth. Southey was experienced in the role of a literary mentor, having dispensed similar advice to a young Shelley in 1811. This led to a discussion of how writers perceived themselves, given that terms like ‘Romantic’ and ‘the Lake Poets’, were coined retrospectively. Particularly interesting were parallels between Charlotte’s and Southey’s portrayal of ‘dosing’ unfortunate victims with Wordsworthian verse in the 1830s, and Byron’s complaint that Shelley had ‘dosed him with Wordsworth physic until sick’, when composing the Third Canto of Childe Harold’s Pilgrimage in 1816.


Finally, we thought about how these writers presented each other in poetry and prose. Hartley Coleridge’s pastiche of Wordsworth was revealing, especially in terms of highlighting the decline of the latter’s brilliance. We also considered Charlotte’s mischievous portrayal of Branwell’s poetic persona. This reflected her bitterness that it was acceptable for a man to write and not so for a woman. An interesting point was made about Charlotte’s identification with the eighteenth-century tradition, and her subversion of gender when comparing herself to Charles Grandison’s writing on ‘perfect manliness’. We concluded by thinking about what this correspondence said about patronage, celebrity and the act of sending and receiving letters. We considered it refreshing that young writers felt able to engage intellectually with their predecessors, and what this reveals about nineteenth-century literary culture. Overall, the session was very interesting, and drew attention to themes that linked our various research interests.



By Leanne Stokoe, Newcastle University.

18 comments:

  1. Best places to obtain: No matter what omega replica you happen to be looking for, you must get your main concern for you to calculate your capacity to pay. You should evidently be aware that the amount you'll be able to find the money for to the necklaces you happen to be gonna rolex replica submariner invest in. Than the jewelries offering inside enterprise merchants. Mylittlesecretbox. com will be the position to find the several variety of developer duplicate necklaces. This specific necklaces in addition crafted from your okay resources which in turn is known to create the main developer versions. As a result, fake omega normally incorporates excellent. It's also possible to obtain these kind of jewelries on-line on each of our internet site mylittlesecretbox. com. A number of duplicate necklaces designers try and offer pockets replica watches uk in somewhat important price ranges. Using modest look for, you will get to your reputable along with trusted seller who has distinguished pertaining to the solutions along with good quality solutions. Inside replica hublot very same fashion, certainly not most of these people are generally truthful using organization and they are making money by simply giving drastically wrong goods in replica rolex gmt high-priced price ranges. Therefore, you should use caution while getting a False Enjoy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In many ways, this unique latest chronograph not to mention GMT louis vuitton replica sale variety of this Omega Seamaster 300M can be described as limited renovate in the Seamaster 300M Co-Axial Chronograph, and yet accompanied by a changed dial not to mention GMT personally. Which may be NOW when camping, considering that I just still find it a powerful companion from a fascinating have. Omega genuinely seems to have various chronograph GMT looks after for instance the gucci replica sale Aqua Terra Chronograph GMT aided by the in-house developed quality 9605, nonetheless design and style is different as opposed to at the Seamaster hermes replica sale 300M Co-Axial Chronograph GMT. In any all steel metal claim accompanied by a matte darkness grey ceramic bezel, typically the Omega rolex replica sale Seamaster 300M through this develop might be 44mm tremendous not to mention the right way fluffy at the hand. Whenever a what you are able to assert on the subject of rolex replica sale Omega get looks after it happens to be construct y can make for some dazzling appearance at the hand : certainly typically the chronograph devices. I'm keen chronograph GMT looks after for the purpose of moving around as i are able to instance a number of important things not to mention have a relatively useful resource enough time to residential.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The bottom line: mass-market luxury items gucci replica are everywhere today, and they form one of the fastest replica louis vuitton growing segments of consumer products. Steve Jobs chanel replica is smart enough to tap into that trend iwc replica with a unique product. And he's going to sell ubout replica millions of them at quite healthy profit margins as a result.

    ReplyDelete
  4. According to Rolex Daytona Buzzfeed, some UK universities are resorting to banning all Replica Watches from their exam rooms, as examiners can’t really be expected to reliably identify which Replica handbags are and which Replica watches UK are just naturally enormously thick and cumbersome and perpetually out of charge.London’s City University told the site: “Students handbag replica are already asked to place mobile phones in a plastic wallet under their desk, so we adopted.

    ReplyDelete
  5. In the event that you as of now have a current home loan and might want to renegotiate it with an alternate advance, a remortgage is likewise conceivable. So also, a home loan number cruncher will be convenient in figuring for the month to month amortization under your rebuilt lodging contract. Check Cashing San-diego

    ReplyDelete
  6. may be useful for all, helpful article once and pardon me permission to share also here

    Cara menyembuhkan gerd
    Obat radang lambung
    Obat tulang retak

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi, I'm Anshita Sharma demonstrate Girl. Marvelous blogging, I adored the data on your websites. These are exceptionally great, as these are extremely creative. much appreciated Gurgaon Escorts Service

    ReplyDelete
  8. Such a very useful article. Very interesting to read this article. I would like to thank you for the efforts.
    great post

    ReplyDelete

  9. Gurgaon Escorts
    Escorts in Gurgaonis one of the most colorful and cultural city of Call Girl in Gurgaon and since it is the capital city, providing ample opportunities Gurgaon Escort Service for various sectors including jobs, is a must here. Female Escorts in Gurgaon There are numerous good universities here which attracts students from all over the world and apart from that it is also emerging as one of the peaceful and safest city to work in. Independent Escorts in GurgaonLooking at all these parameters, many people come to this city with a dream and most of them are able to achieve them with some efforts.
    Escorts in Gurgaon Service

    ReplyDelete